Tuesday, November 17, 2026Tue, Nov 17 AboutRSSSubscribe

ABM Fuel

Account-based marketing and demand generation

News

Marketers Disagree On Creator Economy Definitions

The creator economy lacks standardization, with different brands using varying definitions for creators, making measurement and cost challenging. This discrepancy may hinder the industry's growth.

Original reporting · digiday.com

Original: “What exactly counts as a creator? The industry still can’t agree”

Read “What exactly counts as a creator? The industry still can’t agree” at Digiday →
What exactly counts as a creator? The industry still can’t agree
Image: Digiday

How this was written. ABM Fuel wrote this article with a language model from Digiday’s reporting (model: @cf/meta/llama-3.3-70b-instruct-fp8-fast); it describes that reporting rather than adding to it. The original, linked above, is the full story.

Key points from Digiday’s report

  • The creator economy lacks a unified definition of what constitutes a creator, hindering standardization and growth.
  • Different brands have varying definitions and classification systems for creators, making comparison and evaluation challenging.
  • The industry expects greater clarity around inputs and expected outcomes to set goals and allocate budgets for creator partnerships.
  • The lack of standardization may lead to undervalued work and make it harder to justify investment in creator partnerships.
  • Agencies and brands are developing their own approaches to creator classification, highlighting the need for a unified system.

The creator economy has grown significantly, but the industry still lacks a unified definition of what constitutes a creator, according to Digiday. Marketers have been trying to standardize various aspects, including creator taxonomy, measurement, and deal fee structures.

The lack of standardization may hinder the industry's growth, as it makes it challenging to measure the effectiveness of creator partnerships and determine their costs. At least 23% of marketers believe that a unified creator taxonomy would benefit the industry, as stated in the IAB's latest creator economy report.

General Mills has a nuanced approach to creator definitions, with a tiered system that includes celebrity status, mega creators, mid creators, super fans, and friends and family. Each tier has distinct characteristics, such as the level of social media followers or the type of partnership.

Other brands, such as Shutterfly and Rothy's, also have their own creator classification systems. Shutterfly's system includes tastemakers, influencers, and content creators, while Rothy's defines creators based on their cultural relevance. The lack of a standard naming system across the industry makes it challenging to compare and evaluate creator partnerships.

Agencies also have their own approaches to creator classification. VML, for example, organizes creators by their role in a campaign, such as salespeople, brand ambassadors, or product collaborators. The agency's global executive director, Noah Eisemann, notes that every influencer is a creator, but not every creator is an influencer.

The creator economy has evolved to include various roles, such as actors, product collaborators, and creative agencies. This shift has made it essential to define the role a creator plays in a particular strategy to determine the value of the partnership and measure its success.

The lack of standardization in creator definitions may lead to undervalued work and make it harder to justify investment in creator partnerships. As the industry continues to grow, marketers expect greater clarity around inputs and expected outcomes to set goals, allocate budgets, and define the role creators play in the broader advertising landscape.

Questions and answers

What is the main challenge in the creator economy?

The main challenge is the lack of standardization in creator definitions, making measurement and cost challenging.

How do brands classify creators?

Brands have different classification systems, such as General Mills' tiered system, Shutterfly's tastemakers, influencers, and content creators, and Rothy's cultural relevance-based system.

What is the expected outcome of the lack of standardization?

The lack of standardization may lead to undervalued work and make it harder to justify investment in creator partnerships, according to Stefani Stamatiou, CEO of Americas at HYDP creator marketing agency.

Read the full story at Digiday More from Tuesday, November 17, 2026’s edition